Jul 05, 2009 one of the differences is that part of the film is on colour while the books are blackandwhite. The book ends with a 14yearold marji, palms pressed against the airports dividing glass, her chadorframed face a mask of horror, looking back at her. Persepolis is a completed autobiographical series of comics bande dessinee by marjane satrapi that depicts her childhood up to her early adult years in iran during and after the islamic revolution. In the book, persepolis, by marjane satrapi, the main character is the author as a young girl growing up in iran during the islamic revolution of 1979. What are the differences between the marjane satrapis autobiographical graphic novel persepolis, and the animated movie adaption. In persepolis, marjane lives in tehran, which is subject to relentless bombing throughout marjanes childhood there. It is a cartoon, as the book is a comic, and it is also in french. I, like many people my age these days, did not read enough when i was little. While neither the movie argo, nor the graphic novel persepolis make any reference to the iranian cultural revolution as a conspiracy, they both confirmed that i only know as much about history as my cultures news media will allow me to know, unless i do the research on my own. In the animated persepolis, marjane satrapi retells her tale of youthful rebellion in iran. Similarly, if the movie version had been conventionally cast and. The main idea being for us to look at how satrapi evolved into a grown women with struggles along the way.
Aug 01, 2019 persepolis and pasargadae, traveling for a glimpse into irans glorious history angela corrias august 1, 2019 many are the posts ive already written about the capital of irans fars province, describing the romance shiraz never fails to evoke and the colours and reflections of the enchanted nasir almulk mosque from inside and outside. First lets start with the book and then finish with the movie. Marjane satrapi says she wrote her book persepolis because after she fled iran following the islamic revolution, people kept asking her what. The first thing we learn about marjis mom is that shes pretty revolutionary. Because the book is both graphics and text, its visual difference from the film is less than in a film adaptatio n of a text only work, like prouxs short story. Marjane satrapis persepolis is a memoir, in cartoon form, of her.
A movieadaptation is the transfer of a written work. Many of her friends and family members also either serve in the war or are prisoners of war. Argo and persepolis are yet even more proof that this is the case. Marjane satrapis bestselling, internationally acclaimed graphic memoir. Differences between the graphic novel and film, persepolis. Identify at least three ways the book and the movie are similar and three ways they are different for the setting, characters, plot, and resolution.
Research and describe the term coming of age movie a. Graphic novel after viewing the movie version of persepolis, i only felt disappointment. Even though the movie did a great job making the book come to life, the movie and book had a couple differences. Like marjane satrapis book, on which it is based, the film, directed by ms. The movie is just around 2 hours so the movie had to leave out some scenes and shorten roles in order to fit the time limit. Persepolis was released as a graphic novel in 2000 and was semi autographical. The film persepolis is originated from the comic book. Satrapi talks about how friends and relatives were tortured. By reading the book and discussing in class little by little as we our reading progressed really helped me to get a better view on the movie. Persepolis and pasargadae, traveling for a glimpse into iran.
A comparison posted on november 15, 20 by angela ho marjane satrapis book, persepolis 2. Apr 17, 2009 when comparing the book and movie of persepolis, there are many resembling instances. While the book attempts to tell the dramatic story of marji satrapi, the film intends to more directly educate the viewer about iranian historyleaving out. Persepolis opens right after the 1979 iranian revolution, which results in the downfall of the americanbacked dictator known as the shah of iran and leads to the rise of the religious hardliners who establish the oppressive islamic republic. Apr 03, 20 the film version of persepolis stays true to the overall tone and style of the graphic novel, yet, its intention is slightly different. This movie has been translated into three languages, but the original was done in french. So after hours of reading and watching the movie a thousand times i feel safe to compare and contrast the differences i found. The movie never brought up mitchs brother like they did in the book. While the book attempts to tell the dramatic story of marji satrapi, the film intends to more directly educate the viewer about iranian historyleaving out many scenes of marji in austria. Though, when it comes to creating a film based off of a book filmmakers tend to slightly skew what is. Whenever your essay topic involves comparison, you can organize in either of two ways. Persepolis and pasargadae, traveling for a glimpse into. The film version of persepolis stays true to the overall tone and style of the graphic novel, yet, its intention is slightly different. May 09, 2012 the film rendition of the book is exactly like the book.
I admired the authors successful attempt at showing the dilemmas of a young woman throughout her life concerned with remembering the past during the iraniraq war. The movie was good but was very different than the play. I think reza was portrayed in such a way to emphasise how different marjane was in comparison to the norm in iran. Why its difficult to make a movie from a comic book mpr news. What are the differences between the book and movie.
There is also an amazing film adaption by the same name and. Compare and contrast the book and the film, look for similarities and differences in how the same. But there were also some parts of the movie that had left out some parts that were in the book. Movie and book comparison essay examples essay example. What are the differences between the book and movie versions. It might seem that her story is too large for one 98minute film, but persepolis tells it carefully, lovingly and with great style. Both the kite runner and persepolis relate their stories based on childhood. Persepolis is a 2007 adult animated film based upon the marjane satrapi autobiographical graphic novel of the same name. Marjane satrapi describes how she used to attend a french coeducational and nonreligious school, but how this is outlawed because the islamic republic. Hamlet compare and contrast the book and the movie. For this reason, you might want to consider one of the following approaches to writing your paper.
And, to be fair, persepolis does include a certain amount of violence and especially in its second volume a certain amount of sex. Persepolis is a book by marjane satrapi written about her own life as a young iranian woman around and during the islamic revolution. Persepolis book vs persepolis movie essay 538 words bartleby. Throughout this time period, women were forced to wear oppressive veils and very covering clothing to shield their bodies from the delicate mens eyes. The movie shares a number of similarities with the book. Students then design new dvd covers and a related insert for the movies, reflecting their response to the movie version. She was at an airport daydreaming and began to have a flashback of her life story in black and white, which is different from the beginning of the novel. It was written and directed by satrapi in collaboration with vincent paronnaud. The story follows a young girl as she comes of age against the backdrop of the iranian revolution. Nov 20, 2007 persepolis is the poignant story of a young girl in iran during the islamic revolution. Differences between the graphic novel and film, persepolis, by. Persepolis explores what its like to grow up in iran, and to be misunderstood no matter where you go simply because of where you came from. In responding to these types of prompts, you often will compare and contrast characters, concepts, or choices. Overall i thought the book and movie were very similar.
Persepolis is a comic book describing the struggle of an iranian girl under extremist governments. Words are, of course, the most powerful drug used by mankind. To counter that, some see the solution to create a movie based on the literary work to help better capture the accuracy that the book attempts to achieve by visualizing the events. Persepolis why is childhood such an important time of life. The notable thing is that, as is mostly expected when a book is adapted into a movie, the persepolis movie also deviates from the book in certain ways. The story is about a young marjane growing up in iran during the shah dynasty, iranian. In the beginning of the movie, i do not think i would have grasped the.
Hamlet compare and contrast the book and the movie after watching the ethan hawke version of hamlet and reading the play in class i concluded that there was many differences and was similar at some part. Rebellion in persepolis essay examples 6 words cram. The first chapter of the book, the veil opens with the description. May 01, 2017 persepolis, first a graphic novel, was later produced into an animated biographical film. However, certain omissions and changes from the original literature, no matter how minor, can change the meaning. One last thing that the book and movie had in common was that each time mitch went to visit morrie he could tell morrie was getting worse and worse. Feb 19, 2016 my thoughts on the graphic novel persepolis, written and illustrated by marjane satrapi and translated by mattias ripa and blake ferris. Persepolis summary from litcharts the creators of sparknotes. I found marjan satrapis persepolis among the stacks of books that a friend of my grandmother had given us. Movie after reading persepolis, i was very impressed with the graphic novel. Persepolis book vs persepolis movie she was at an airport daydreaming and began to have a flashback of her life story in black and white, which is different from the beginning of the novel. Comparing and contrasting kite runner and persepolis by.
The story follows author and director, marjane satrapi, through her young childhood years into her life as an adult during the islamic revolution. This text list includes books and their corresponding movies that are appropriate for the middle school classroom. What are the main differences marjane notices between living in vienna and living in iran. She makes it perfectly clear that war is hell, no matter how you experience it. Throughout this time period, women were forced to wear oppressive veils and very covering clothing to. The comparisons she has earned to art spiegelman, whose maus. Compare and contrast this type of writing assignment is common on a standardized test, you may be asked to analyze literature, evaluate ideas, or make a judgment and explain your reasons. Persepolis is the name of the ancient capital of persia, now iran. Persepolis is a 2007 animated film based on marjane satrapis autobiographical graphic novel of the same name. The most common form of a movie adaptation is the use of a novel, such as the book persepolis, written by marjane satrapi, written as a childhood memoir. Persepolis is a graphic novel in case you dont know, this is like a longformat comic book. What are the differences between the book and movie versions of persepolis. So, of course, the images are essential to the text. List your ideas in bullet form, and cite evidence from the book and the movie.
How do you write a paper on comparing a movie with the book. Conclusion both characters in the end of the two books are both similar in many ways, but there were many differences between the both of them. Compare and contrast themes from other texts to this theme. It was, however, nominated for best animated feature.
Persepolis and pasargadae, traveling for a glimpse into irans glorious history angela corrias august 1, 2019 many are the posts ive already written about the capital of irans fars province, describing the romance shiraz never fails to evoke and the colours and reflections of the enchanted nasir almulk mosque from inside and outside. I believe that if i had viewed the movie without reading the graphic novel, i would have considered it to be a great film. Oct 16, 2019 the movie shares a number of similarities with the book. Compare and contrast the death of uncle anoosh with. The most common form of a movieadaptation is the use of a novel, such as the book persepolis, written by marjane satrapi, written as a childhood memoir. Persepolis is an absolutely amazing book, filled with happiness, grief and moments of childhood in a world where all children are forced to grow up. The title persepolis is a reference to the ancient capital of the persian empire.
Persepolis book vs persepolis movie essay 538 words. It is through the eyes of precocious and outspoken nine year old marjane that we see a peoples hopes dashed. Similarly in 1984, winstons wife katherine was also extremely similar and extremely conservative. A common debate that often occurs is if the book or the film provides a better narrative. Marjane is ten years old in 1980 when the novel begins. Maus has won a lot of accolades and is probably the first comic book to be taken seriously.
The film slightly better portrayed the feelings involved throughout the story simply because there were voice overs so the viewers had a chance to put voices to the faces and words in the books. Jan 17, 2008 although france selected persepolis as its official oscar entry in the foreignlanguage category, the film was not among the nine titles chosen for the second round of nominations. Comparison and contrast persepolis the film and the comic book. Get everything you need to know about the personal vs. Persepolis and fun home laura sneddons third week of comic studies focused on two very different autobiographix by female creators in marjane satrapis persepolis and alison bechdels fun home. Persepolis the book i, like many people my age these days, did not read enough when i was little. The beginning of the novel dove straight into her life story in black and white.
I will tell you which one i like best and which movie adaptation i think deserves to move to the next round as the outright clear winner of this round. A movie adaptation is the transfer of a written work. In both books, innocent people were being beaten viciously. Marjane satrapis persepolis is the latest and one of the most delectable examples of a booming postmodern genre. First, you can write about each thing separately and then include a section in which you make comparisons and contrasts between them. In the graphic novels persepolis and maus, drawings are used to show events and emotions better. The first chapter of the book, the veil opens with the.
After all, he was supposed to be so intelligent and wise. As a result, though my reading comprehension is good, my reading speed is below collegelevel standards. She starts off as an incredibly positive child with enormous faith in herself and her relationship with gd. Both rulers used a physical force to try and control their people. A story of return, brilliantly illustrates a comingofage story, where young marji struggles with her iranian identity and history, all the while dealing with her frustration and loneliness in vienna. Both the book and movie attempt to display a sense of what it was like to want to live life a certain way but having to abide by rules that put your life in danger when broken. Persepolis by marjane satrapi and vincent paronnaud core. But that is expected as the book is what gives birth to the movie. What is a motif, and how can i find them in macbeth. Though i have not read persepolis 2, the first part of the movie was basically identical. Supposedly, comics are the junk food of literature classics the vegetables.
318 175 206 1453 1059 63 656 610 147 1483 1318 970 800 1204 1175 1137 1122 193 230 733 452 1214 1349 1371 539 1358 1086 31 548 26 1418 1317 443 701 751 1477 968